
Self-portrait
Look at you perched there on the courthouse pew – on the seat beside you is your good purse stuffed with kleenex and humbugs and pictures of your kids; your plump legs crossed demurely at your thick ankles; your swollen feet stuffed into cheap pumps.
You clutch a tissue in your naked fingers. There is an indentation in the puffy flesh of your ring finger that is just beginning to fill in. You fiddle with the tissue, you pull at the hem of your best dress, your only dress, that is tight at the hips and the waist. You haven’t worn it for years. You wish you could afford something better.
Your hair is black silk, gray at the roots, tucked into a messy bun. You think it makes you look more sophisticated but your up-do reveals your thick neck, encircled with crevices like the rings of a tree, and the wiry hairs sprouting out of your double chin.
Your eyes are downcast.
You don’t want people to see you have been crying. Even though that’s all you’ve been doing for months. Your eyes aren’t blue anymore, they are perpetually bloodshot and swollen.
What once sparkled in you is now dead and muffled, like the airlessness of a soundproofed room.
You were once the secretary at the optometrist’s office. You were a volunteer at the public school. You were a mother and a wife. You had friends.
And now look at you.
Charged with assault. Sitting alone in a sea of hillbilly heroin-addicted thieves and murderous drunk drivers, impotent slack-eyed rapists and hair-fisted, hair-triggered bullies. Waiting for your turn in front of the judge.
You are afraid someone respectable might see you. But there is no one respectable here. Not the married judge with the hairless, empty sac who is banging the vapid recording secretary. Not the Crown attorney, who puts bad guys behind bars because it makes him feel less guilty about sexually molesting his 12-year-old stepdaughter. Certainly not the legal aid lawyer who feels cheated because he couldn’t land a job at a big-city firm and now takes out his resentment on the penniless, hopeless, useless clients he is forced to defend.
Doesn’t matter, their own foibles. On paper, they look good. On paper, you are charged with hitting your husband of 19 years. You will likely be found guilty, because you did hit him. You will carry a criminal record for the rest of your life like Atlas would carry the world on his shoulders, or Christ carried the cross. You will bear the guilt, the shame, and it will crush your spirit, your pride, your soul.
But the worst thing is this: because of your criminal record, you will never win custody of your children. They will be awarded to the man you once trusted and loved, the man who lied to you, who cheated on you, who ripped your world apart like it was made of tissue paper and then stomped on your broken heart and laughed while he was doing it.
I don't feel sorry for you, stupid woman.
This is your fault.
And this is why: on the night you found out he was cheating, you threw him out. Which is good, which is smart, which is the right thing to do.
You blew it three days later, though, when he came crawling back to you, crying his lying, cheating, no-good eyes out.
He had no place to go, he said.
He was sleeping in the car, he said.
Could he stay in the house? At least until he got his life together and found a place of his own?
"I guess," you said.
It was like giving a vampire permission to cross the threshold.
You became stupid at that very moment.
There are some who would think you a nice person for allowing him back. Others would think you a martyr. Or a true believer in the sanctity of marriage. He was, after all, your husband.
You owed him that much.
Right?
No, you stupid, stupid cow.
A few days later, with emotions running on a tenterhook the shaved thinness of a sharp blade, you and he had a knock-down, drag-out brawl. He called you every name in the book. You hit him. And god, he deserved it. Your kids screamed. Neighbours called the cops. The next thing you knew you were sitting in the back of a police cruiser, your hands cuffed behind your back, your hair hanging in your face.
The last thing you saw as the cruiser pulled out of the driveway was the faces of your babies staring open-mouthed at you through the living room window.
And now you sit in a crowded courtroom, wondering how your respectable life disintegrated into this heaving pile of steaming shit.
Don't wonder. It's perfectly clear.
You were born stupid.
You were born female.
It is the cross we must all bear.
What a miserable existence for this poor woman! Your description made me ache for her. So out of shape, so dispirited, so pitiful.
ReplyDeleteI do think she let him back because of compassion. But, unfortunately, it was a self-defeating thing to do at the end of it all.
How sad for the children. Hope they're not girls.
Wow. This is like molten lava. "Heaving pile of steaming shit." Somebody's going to ask why you put a self portrait at the head of this. Not me. I don't have the guts.
ReplyDeletequite the portrait this - heartbreaking, and feels more true than I'm comfortable with (!)
ReplyDeleteI feel so sorry for her, with her fat ankles and all.
That self portrait is outstanding, who is the artist?
One minor issue, if you don't mind- a bit more space between paragraphs would make for easier reading. You normally have this, so forgive me if this is a specific thing for this week!
Marisa: I saw this woman in a courtroom once and really felt her discomfiture. She honestly didn't belong there; she didn't deserve it. Why is it, in marital strife, it is almost never the true victim who winds up paying a price? Breaking a heart isn't illegal.. but maybe it should be.
ReplyDeleteMark: Thank you. Molten lava... I can now die happy.
Mazzz: Here I am, supposed graphic designer extraordinaire, and I can't figure out how to change the leading in this g.d. program... sheesh. Anyway, I lightened it up best I could. Hope that helps. Dave, my partner, took this photo of me a long time ago. I was stirring a pot of pasta and for some reason that made me look sad. I brought it into photoshop tonight, blowing out the detail and turning it into something I like so much I might stick in a frame. I could call it "al dente."
Holy holy cow, Cathy!
ReplyDeleteThis is intense and seething, and angry and fantastic. The details are so vivid. The repetition of 'stupid' and 'stupid woman' just killed me. I have hurled that at myself too many times to count and I can assure you this has left such a mark that I don't believe I ever will again.
You've created a character that will stay with me.
And that photograph, so haunting and beautiful.
well, ... a courageous story.
ReplyDeleteRaw, blistering, descriptions and you have to wonder how the narrator is related to the woman. It takes a closeness to call out the truth. It's almost like she is talking about herself or it's written by a sister. The voice makes it for sure. Well done.
ReplyDeleteA great story of exasperation, loathing and ultimately destructiveness. Why do we even have children? It infantilises us all and removes us from society, or we neglect them in order to try and carry on as before.
ReplyDeleteTough stuff. Tough love.
marc nash
OMG. This hurt to read, but I was carried along to the end. Not only the details of the 'stupid woman' but the details of all the court players maintained the tone and the bleak perspective of this version of reality.
ReplyDeleteraw like an open wound, festering, hopeless, honest. The self-portrait is beautiful, as is the story. Very, very powerful.
I identify with this woman. Let's be glad I never became her. That sonabitch deserved it, didn't he?
ReplyDeleteMen are worse than stupid women. They are clever and sometimes learn how to puppet the system.
This is not so much a story but an over-and-over-and-over repeating reality.
ReplyDeleteI would have liked to know more about the narrator. How does he/she come to know so much about the woman? Sometimes it seems as if it is a spectator, sometimes it seems as if he/she was with her the whole time.
"You will carry a criminal record for the rest of your life like Atlas would carry the world on his shoulders, or Christ carried the cross. You will bear the guilt, the shame, and it will crush your spirit, your pride, your soul." This is just one example of the brilliant phrasing in this piece.
ReplyDeleteThis flowed very well and you quickly let us know the outcome. She was doomed from the very beginning.
Beautifully done!
ReplyDeleteYou may not appreciate the comparison, but this reminded me of an Ed Brubaker issue of the comic Daredevil. The whole issue was narrated in a third person who scorned the character, Wilson Fisk, but was so intimate in its knowledge and the reasons for its pain that it became heartbreakingly apparent Fisk was actually narrating at himself. Halfway through I can't believe anyone is speaking this story but the lady (though obviously you're writing about someone you saw in a court room). Ironically Brubaker's story was about falling in love and fearing he would ruin everything, where your tale is about everything having gone wrong. The authentic, intimate bitterness is there. I normally hate stories that abound in negativity, but you and Brubaker got through my biases to make me genuinely feel for these damaged people.
ReplyDeleteRivetting! I can relate to being a sucker...
ReplyDeleteThis weblog is being featured on Five Star Friday!
ReplyDeletehttp://www.fivestarfriday.com/2010/03/five-star-fridays-edition-95.html
Seems weird to write this given the subject of the post...but Congrats on the Five Star Friday. Your page lept out at me...I live about 30 mins south in Coldwater so when I saw Muskoka River I had to look! :) I found your blog through a person I read in BC who also made the list.
ReplyDeleteHard hitting, straight talking, flying Valkyrie fantastic fiction! Cathy, I read this over and over again. It seethes with vituperative anger, cynicism and honesty. Bravo - I love this piece.
ReplyDeleteSimon.
Simon has it - vituperative.
ReplyDeleteSo, the narrator was the woman? Her dark self-conscious.
Some very good detailing and descriptions going on in here, although I did wonder why rapists were characterised as impotent?
Wow, Cathy! Raw, and like Mark said, molten lava. So many women march down this path blindfolded. Superb narrative!
ReplyDeleteAnger pouring off the page! Awesome piece, second person just amps up the emotion. Best piece of self-loathing I've read in a long, long time.
ReplyDeleteWow. Off to read... again.
The voice in this couldn't be more perfect - the bitterness, the scorn heaped on all involved and on the woman is palpable. The only people left untouched by the bile heaped upon the characters are the children. As usual, the kids are the ones that get to be horrified observers in the stupid, stupid world of adults.
ReplyDeleteWow, everyone else captured what I also got from this piece - raw self-loathing and bitterness. I felt like I was hearing inside her head - you captured her thoughts and feelings so well. It was hard to read because I felt so sorry for her - but it is very realistic!
ReplyDeleteWhat a terrible horrible situation -eloquently told.
ReplyDeleteYou wrote an excellent story here. Raw, gritty, and full of emotion and heartache. Well done!
ReplyDeleteThat was an incredible tirade against the poor woman! By the end, I saw it as her inner voice, having finally gotten objectivity, but too late and at too great a price. Does stupid mean trusting?
ReplyDeleteCD